International Workshop on ‘Sustainable Public Procurement: Research Trends and New Challenges’
The Center for Institutional Studies (CInSt), at HSE, is hosting a workshop on 4 - 5 October, 2013 on aspects of sustainable public procurement. How to improve it, reduce corruption and use it as an instrument of economic growth, and how to apply new research results to do so. The international workshop brings together researchers fromThe Economics of Public Private Partnerships Chair (Chaire-EPPP, Paris) and the Department of Economics and Management at the University of Padova (DSEA, Padova) and from the HSE’s CInSt. The HSE news portal asked three of the participants to answer some questions in advance of the workshop.
Paola Valbonesi, Ph.D, Associate Professor at the Department of Economics and Management at the University of Padova will give a talk on Friday 4 October - Court efficiency and procurement performance. Carine Staropoli, Associate Professor at the Centre d'Economie de la Sorbonne - Université Paris I,will chair a discussion on 5 October entitled Capture for the Rich, Extortion for the Poor.And Elena Podkolzina, Deputy Director of the HSE Centre for Institutional Studies, will chair the session on Friday and lead a discussion about Collusion detection in Russian highway construction on Saturday.
We started by asking each of them, why is public procurement important for economic and sustainable growth?
Carine pointed out that, ‘For OECD countries, Public procurement accounts for on average 19% of GDP. So this is very important for economic growth. Lately Public Procurement regulation has imposed more and more constraints in order to incorporate sustainable dimensions (social and environmental) into public contracts. These new constraints are likely to have a significant impact on sustainable growth.’
While Paola, bearing in mind the current austerity measures imposed on many European countries says cautiously that, ‘In a time of scarce public resources, money spent in public procurement should be spent carefully and with the aim of driving economic growth. The current challenges raise opportunities for a new way of managing public-private contracts. Economic and sustainable growth is the agenda, and public procurement gives resources to address those aims but governments need to adopt new tools and processes. Unfortunately, we know that public administrations - and bureaucracy in general - are less prone than businesses to take up challenges, but this is where research comes in to support institutional change.
Elena is unequivocal. She says, ‘It is extremely important. It determines the ways state agencies spend money.’
As it is an international workshop the question arises, can we compare the efficiency of public procurement in Russia and other countries? If yes, what are we looking for? If no, why involve foreign researchers in a domestic issue?
Carine makes it clear that, ‘The objectives of public procurement should be the same in every country even if procurement policy is embedded in the institutional environment and has to take into account each country's specificities. The main efficiency objective is "value for money" - better services and goods supplied at lower costs. Russia seems to be trying hard to make public procurement more transparent and more efficient by reducing corruption and increasing competition pressure. In Europe too, Public procurement aims to increase competition within the larger internal market to have more market integration, but also more transparency and to reduce corruption and unnecessary expense, especially under growing budget constraints. Europe has conceived new tools and policies and is due to adopt a new directive replacing 2004/17/CE and 2004/18/CE based on the proposition of 2011.’
And in general terms, Paola agrees with Carine, she says that, “Public procurement is a highly regulated process everywhere, which can contain very different features. It is important to compare the effect of the different regulations to choose the most effective rules for specific policy objectives.’
 |
| Elena Podkolzina |
Carine told us about trends in the latest research and whether she thinks results can be used in the real economic sector: ‘Green public procurement that aims at "greening" all public investments by giving more weight to environmentally friendly goods and services is clearly a priority. The policy in favor of Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) is another. This passes through new procedures in awarding contracts (using multiple criteria to select the best candidate) and contract design (to reduce enforcement costs and renegotiation). These objectives will certainly have a strong impact on real economic sector activity, increasing sustainable growth’.
And Elena explained why there is a gap between the focus of interest in European and Russian research, ‘Green procurement is one of the hottest topics in Europe. Russian research focuses mainly on the efficiency of public procurement. The reason for this gap is that research reflects the situation in the economy. In Russia we have too much focus on competition mechanism and researchers are arguing that the role of reputation should be expanded. There is no unique answer what is the best way to organize procurement process, how to solve the reputation-corruption dilemma. We should look at these issues from different points and produce policy implications based on theoretical background. These are the kind of issues HSE researchers from CInst and IIMS are investigating.’
Anna Chernyakhovskaya, specially for the HSE news serviceSee also:
FES Announces the Winner of the Nobel Prize in Economics 2024 Prediction Contest
The HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences summarised the results of its traditional prediction contest. FES holds this contest annually on the eve of Nobel Week. This year, the contest once again attracted participants from different regions of Russia and countries around the world. Remarkably, one participant managed to predict all three laureates of the 2024 Economics Prize.
Try Your Hand at Predicting the 2024 Nobel Prize Winner in Economics
The Faculty of Economic Sciences is launching its annual prediction contest. On October 14, the Nobel Committee will announce the winners of the Sveriges Riksbank Alfred Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences live on air. You have time to prepare and explore the landscape of contemporary economic thought. What topics and areas are considered particularly important and promising at the moment? Anyone can win.
Choosing the Right Server Results in Better Outcomes in Doubles Tennis
The Roland Garros tennis tournament, one of the most prestigious in the world, began on May 26. The prize money for this year's French Open totals nearly 54 million euros, with athletes competing in both singles and doubles events. In doubles tennis, choosing the right strategy for a match is crucial. Athletes' ability to adapt to the dynamics of the match and strategically choose the server can earn the pair up to 5% more points, according to Nikolai Avkhimovich, doctoral student and research fellow at the Laboratory of Sports Studies of the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences. A paper with the study findings has been published in Applied Economics.
Consumer Prices Decrease in Densely Populated Areas
HSE University economists have proposed a novel approach to modelling monopolistic competition with heterogeneous firms and consumers. The results of collaborative research carried out by Alexander Tarasov from Moscow, his co-authors from HSE University–St Petersburg, together with the Norwegian School of Economics, the University of Pennsylvania, and the Free University of Brussels, have been published in American Economic Journal: Microeconomics.
Football Players Cover Greater Distances During Critical Derby Matches at Home Arena
Researchers at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences examined the level of effort that professional football players are willing to exert during a match in absence of financial incentives. It appears that the primary factors driving players to strive harder for victory are the strength of the opponent and the significance of the match for the club. This is particularly noticeable in derby matches between teams from the same city, such as the Moscow derby between CSKA and Spartak on April 25, 2024. The study has been published in the Journal of the New Economic Association.
Participation in Crowdfunding Can Generate up to 73% in Returns Annually
Backers of projects on crowdfunding platforms can expect rewards from their pledges. For example, funding someone's idea on Kickstarter can result in an average annual return of 11.5%, with design projects known to deliver returns as high as 70%. However, it is important to note that these returns do not come in the form of direct cash payments but rather as savings on the purchase of the product once it hits the market. This has been demonstrated in a study by researchers at the HSE Faculty of Economics published in Economic Analysis Letters.
Economists Suggest Using Media's Attention to Bitcoin to Predict its Returns
Researchers at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have studied the relationship between the changes in the bitcoin prices and the media attention to this cryptocurrency. The researchers examined the mentions of bitcoin in the media between 2017 and 2021 and built a mathematical model that revealed the strong relationship between media attention and bitcoin prices. The study was published in the Applied Stochastic Models in Business and Industry journal.
HSE Economists Develop a Model for Sustainable Solar Geoengineering Agreements
Researchers at HSE University and George Mason University have investigated the sustainability of prospective international agreements on solar geoengineering. The authors have proposed a scheme in which payments flow from affluent nations to less wealthy ones; an arrangement which sets their proposal apart from traditional systems. The proposed model aims to dissuade more vulnerable countries from excessive use of the prevalent geoengineering method by providing compensation for the potential damage they may incur and supporting their adaptation to climate change. The paper has been published in Environmental and Resource Economics.
Crypto Investors Receive Downside Risk Premiums
Victoria Dobrynskaya, Assistant Professor at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences, has analysed the price dynamics of 2,000 cryptocurrencies from 2014 to 2021 and investigated the association between downside risks and average returns in the cryptocurrency market. As it turns out, cryptocurrencies exhibiting a greater risk tend to yield higher average returns. The study has been published in International Review of Financial Analysis.
Results of the Contest to Predict Nobel Prize Winners in Economics
Claudia Goldin's award was predicted by five people. They are Olga Peresypkina (RSVPU), Anastasia Sirotina (first-year student of the Bachelor's in Applied Mathematics and Information Science at HSE University), Mikhail Shabanov (Global Vision Asset Management LLC), Tatul Hayrapetyan (PhD student at the Stanford Graduate School of Business), and Hemant Kumar (Ettumanoorappan College, Kerala, India).